By Sharon Weinberger
Sunday, January 14, 2007
GIRARD IS CRAZY, HE DOESN’T ACT THE PART. He is standing just where he said he
would be, below the Philadelphia train station’s World War II memorial — a
soaring statue of a winged angel embracing a fallen combatant, as if lifting
him to heaven. Girard is wearing pressed khaki pants, expensive-looking leather
loafers and a crisp blue button-down. He looks like a local businessman dressed
for a casual Friday — a local businessman with a wickedly dark sense of humor,
which had become apparent when he said to look for him beneath “the angel
sodomizing a dead soldier.” At 70, he appears robust and healthy — not
the slightest bit disheveled or unusual-looking. He is also carrying a bag.
description of himself is matter-of-fact, until he explains what’s in the bag:
documents he believes prove that the government is attempting to control his
mind. He carries that black, weathered bag everywhere he goes. “Every time
I go out, I’m prepared to come home and find everything is stolen,” he
The bag aside,
Girard appears intelligent and coherent. At a table in front of Dunkin’ Donuts
inside the train station, Girard opens the bag and pulls out a thick stack of
documents, carefully labeled and sorted with yellow sticky notes bearing neat
block print. The documents are an authentic-looking mix of news stories, articles
culled from military journals and even some declassified national security
documents that do seem to show that the U.S. government has attempted to
develop weapons that send voices into people’s heads.
undeniable that the technology exists,” Girard says, “but if you go
to the police and say, ‘I’m hearing voices,’ they’re going to lock you up for
that’s missing from his bag — the lack of which makes it hard to prove he
isn’t crazy — is even a single document that would buttress the implausible
notion that the government is currently targeting a large group of American
citizens with mind-control technology. The only direct evidence for that,
Girard admits, lies with alleged victims such as himself.
And of those,
there are many.
IT’S 9:01 P.M.
WHEN THE FIRST PERSON SPEAKS during the Saturday conference call.
anyone else is on the line yet, the female caller throws out the first
question: “You got gang stalking or V2K?” she asks no one in
short, uncomfortable pause.
really bad. 24-7,” a man replies.
stalking,” another woman says.
yeah, join the club,” yet another man replies.
members of this confessional “club” are not your usual victims. This
isn’t a group for alcoholics, drug addicts or survivors of childhood abuse; the
people connecting on the call are self-described victims of mind control –
people who believe they have been targeted by a secret government program that
tracks them around the clock, using technology to probe and control their
callers frequently refer to themselves as TIs, which is short for Targeted
Individuals, and talk about V2K — the official military abbreviation stands
for “voice to skull” and denotes weapons that beam voices or sounds
into the head. In their esoteric lexicon, “gang stalking” refers to
the belief that they are being followed and harassed: by neighbors, strangers
or colleagues who are agents for the government.
few more “hellos” are exchanged, interrupted by beeps signaling late
arrivals: Bill from Columbus, Barbara from Philadelphia, Jim from California
and a dozen or so others.
Robinson, the conference call moderator, calls order.
five after 9,” says Robinson, with the sweetly reasonable intonation of a
late-night radio host. “Maybe we should go ahead and start.”
IDEA OF A GROUP OF PEOPLE CONVINCED THEY ARE TARGETED BY WEAPONS that can
invade their minds has become a cultural joke, shorthanded by the image of
solitary lunatics wearing tinfoil hats to deflect invisible mind beams.
“Tinfoil hat,” says Wikipedia, has become “a popular stereotype
and term of derision; the phrase serves as a byword for paranoia and is
associated with conspiracy theorists.”
2005, a group of MIT students conducted a formal study using aluminum foil and
radio signals. Their surprising finding: Tinfoil hats may actually amplify
radio frequency signals. Of course, the tech students meant the study as a
during the Saturday conference call, the subject of aluminum foil is deadly
serious. The MIT study had prompted renewed debate; while a few TIs realized it
was a joke at their expense, some saw the findings as an explanation for why
tinfoil didn’t seem to stop the voices. Others vouched for the material.
helps tremendously,” reports one conference call participant, who
describes wrapping it around her body underneath her clothing.
do you put the tinfoil?” a man asks.
everywhere,” she replies. “I even put it in a hat.”
TI in an online mind-control forum recommends a Web site called “Block
EMF” (as in electromagnetic frequencies), which advertises a full line of
clothing, including aluminum-lined boxer shorts described as a “sheer,
comfortable undergarment you can wear over your regular one to shield yourself
from power lines and computer electric fields, and microwave, radar, and TV
radiation.” Similarly, a tinfoil hat disguised as a regular baseball cap
is “smart and subtle.”
For all the
scorn, the ranks of victims — or people who believe they are victims — are
speaking up. In the course of the evening, there are as many as 40 clicks from
people joining the call, and much larger numbers participate in the online
forum, which has 143 members. A note there mentioning interest from a
journalist prompted more than 200 e-mail responses.
recently, people who believe the government is beaming voices into their heads
would have added social isolation to their catalogue of woes. But now, many
have discovered hundreds, possibly thousands, of others just like them all over
the world. Web sites dedicated to electronic harassment and gang stalking have
popped up in India, China, Japan, South Korea, the United Kingdom, Russia and
elsewhere. Victims have begun to host support meetings in major cities, including
Washington. Favorite topics at the meetings include lessons on how to build
shields (the proverbial tinfoil hats), media and PR training, and possible
legal strategies for outlawing mind control.
hurdle for TIs is getting people to take their concerns seriously. A proposal
made in 2001 by Rep. Dennis Kucinich (D-Ohio) to ban “psychotronic
weapons” (another common term for mind-control technology) was hailed by
TIs as a great step forward. But the bill was widely derided by bloggers and
columnists and quickly dropped.
Kucinich’s spokesman, would not discuss mind control other than to say the
proposal was part of broader legislation outlawing weapons in space. The bill
was later reintroduced, minus the mind control. “It was not the
concentration of the legislation, which is why it was tightened up and
redrafted,” was all Gordon would say.
garner much support from their elected representatives, TIs have started their
own PR campaign. And so, last spring, the Saturday conference calls centered on
plans to hold a rally in Washington. A 2005 attempt at a rally drew a few dozen
people and was ultimately rained out; the TIs were determined to make another
go of it. Conversations focused around designing T-shirts, setting up congressional
appointments, fundraising, creating a new Web site and formalizing a slogan.
After some debate over whether to focus on gang stalking or mind control, the
group came up with a compromise slogan that covered both: “Freedom From
Covert Surveillance and Electronic Harassment.”
call moderator Robinson, who says his gang stalking began when he worked at the
National Security Agency in the 1980s, offers his assessment of the group’s
prospects: Maybe this rally wouldn’t produce much press, but it’s a first step.
“I see this as a movement,” he says. “We’re picking up people
all the time.”
SAYS HIS PROBLEMS BEGAN IN 1983, while he was a real estate developer in Los
Angeles. The harassment was subtle at first: One day a woman pulled up in a
car, wagged her finger at him, then sped away; he saw people running underneath
his window at night; he noticed some of his neighbors seemed to be watching
him; he heard someone moving in the crawl space under his apartment at night.
advice from this then-girlfriend, a practicing psychologist, whom he declines
to identify. He says she told him, “Nobody can become psychotic in their
late 40s.” She said he didn’t seem to manifest other symptoms of psychotic
behavior — he dressed well, paid his bills — and, besides his claims of
surveillance, which sounded paranoid, he behaved normally. “People who are
psychotic are socially isolated,” he recalls her saying.
After a few
months, Girard says, the harassment abruptly stopped. But the respite didn’t
last. In 1984, appropriately enough, things got seriously weird. He’d left his
real estate career to return to school at the University of Pennsylvania, where
he was studying for a master’s degree in landscape architecture. He harbored
dreams of designing parks and public spaces. Then, he says, he began to hear
voices. Girard could distinguish several different male voices, which came
complete with a mental image of how the voices were being generated: from a
recording studio, with “four slops sitting around a card table drinking
beer,” he says.
were crass but also strangely courteous, addressing him as “Mr.
him. They asked him if he thought he was normal; they suggested he was going
crazy. They insulted his classmates: When an overweight student showed up for a
field trip in a white raincoat, they said, “Hey, Mr. Girard, doesn’t she
look like a refrigerator?”
after the voices began, they had another question for him: “Mr. Girard,
Mr. Girard. Why aren’t you dead yet?” At first, he recalls, the voices
would speak just two or three times a day, but it escalated into a
near-constant cacophony, often accompanied by severe pain all over his body –
which Girard now attributes to directed-energy weapons that can shoot invisible
even suggested how he could figure out what was happening to him. He says they
told him to go to the electrical engineering department to “tell them
you’re writing science fiction and you don’t want to write anything
inconsistent with physical reality. Then tell them exactly what has
and got some rudimentary explanations of how technology could explain some of
the things he was describing.
I said: ‘Look, I must come to the point, because I need answers. This is
happening to me; it’s not science fiction.'” They laughed.
He got the
same response from friends, he says. “They regarded me as crazy, which is
a humiliating experience.”
When asked why
he didn’t consult a doctor about the voices and the pain, he says, “I
don’t dare start talking to people because of the potential stigma of it all. I
don’t want to be treated differently. Here I was in Philadelphia. Something was
going on, I don’t know any doctors . . . I know somebody’s doing something to
It was a
struggle to graduate, he says, but he was determined, and he persevered. In
1988, the same year he finished his degree, his father died, leaving Girard an
inheritance large enough that he did not have to work.
So, instead of
becoming a landscape architect, Girard began a full-time investigation of what
was happening to him, often traveling to Washington in pursuit of government
documents relating to mind control. He put an ad in a magazine seeking other
victims. Only a few people responded. But over the years, as he met more and
more people like himself, he grew convinced that he was part of what he calls
an “electronic concentration camp.”
What he was
finding on his research trips also buttressed his belief: Girard learned that
in the 1950s, the CIA had drugged unwitting victims with LSD as part of a rogue
mind-control experiment called MK-ULTRA. He came across references to the CIA
seeking to influence the mind with electromagnetic fields. Then he found
references in an academic research book to work that military researchers at
Walter Reed Army Institute of Research had done in the 1970s with pulsed
microwaves to transmit words that a subject would hear in his head. Elsewhere,
he came across references to attempts to use electromagnetic energy, sound
waves or microwave beams to cause non-lethal pain to the body. For every
symptom he experienced, he believed he found references to a weapon that could
How much of
the research Girard cites checks out?
microwaves and mind control date to the 1960s, when the U.S. government
discovered that its embassy in Moscow was being bombarded by low-level
electromagnetic radiation. In 1965, according to declassified Defense
Department documents, the Pentagon, at the behest of the White House, launched
Project Pandora, top-secret research to explore the behavioral and biological
effects of low-level microwaves. For approximately four years, the Pentagon
conducted secret research: zapping monkeys; exposing unwitting sailors to
microwave radiation; and conducting a host of other unusual experiments (a
sub-project of Project Pandora was titled Project Bizarre). The results were
mixed, and the program was plagued by disagreements and scientific squabbles.
The “Moscow signal,” as it was called, was eventually attributed to
eavesdropping, not mind control, and Pandora ended in 1970. And with it, the
military’s research into so-called non-thermal microwave effects seemed to die
out, at least in the unclassified realm.
But there are
hints of ongoing research: An academic paper written for the Air Force in the
mid-1990s mentions the idea of a weapon that would use sound waves to send
words into a person’s head. “The signal can be a ‘message from God’ that
can warn the enemy of impending doom, or encourage the enemy to
surrender,” the author concluded.
In 2002, the
Air Force Research Laboratory patented precisely such a technology: using
microwaves to send words into someone’s head. That work is frequently cited on
mind-control Web sites. Rich Garcia, a spokesman for the research laboratory’s
directed energy directorate, declined to discuss that patent or current or
related research in the field, citing the lab’s policy not to comment on its
response to a Freedom of Information Act request filed for this article, the
Air Force released unclassified documents surrounding that 2002 patent –
records that note that the patent was based on human experimentation in October
1994 at the Air Force lab, where scientists were able to transmit phrases into
the heads of human subjects, albeit with marginal intelligibility. Research
appeared to continue at least through 2002. Where this work has gone since is
unclear — the research laboratory, citing classification, refused to discuss
it or release other materials.
official U.S. Air Force position is that there are no non-thermal effects of
microwaves. Yet Dennis Bushnell, chief scientist at NASA’s Langley Research
Center, tagged microwave attacks against the human brain as part of future
warfare in a 2001 presentation to the National Defense Industrial Association
about “Future Strategic Issues.”
work is exceedingly sensitive” and unlikely to be reported in any unclassified
documents, he says.
the military’s use of weapons that employ electromagnetic radiation to create
pain is well-known, as are some of the limitations of such weapons. In 2001,
the Pentagon declassified one element of this research: the Active Denial
System, a weapon that uses electromagnetic radiation to heat skin and create an
intense burning sensation. So, yes, there is technology designed to beam
painful invisible rays at humans, but the weapon seems to fall far short of
what could account for many of the TIs’ symptoms. While its exact range is
classified, Doug Beason, an expert in directed-energy weapons, puts it at about
700 meters, and the beam cannot penetrate a number of materials, such as
aluminum. Considering the size of the full-scale weapon, which resembles a
satellite dish, and its operational limitations, the ability of the government
or anyone else to shoot beams at hundreds of people — on city streets, into
their homes and while they travel in cars and planes — is beyond improbable.
given the history of America’s clandestine research, it’s reasonable to assume
that if the defense establishment could develop mind-control or long-distance
ray weapons, it almost certainly would. And, once developed, the possibility that
they might be tested on innocent civilians could not be categorically
for his part, believes these weapons were not only developed but were also
tested on him more than 20 years ago.
would the government gain by torturing him? Again, Girard found what he
believed to be an explanation, or at least a precedent: During the Cold War,
the government conducted radiation experiments on scores of unwitting victims,
essentially using them as human guinea pigs. Girard came to believe that he,
too, was a walking experiment.
that Girard thinks his selection was totally random: He believes he was
targeted because of a disparaging remark he made to a Republican fundraiser
about George H.W. Bush in the early 1980s. Later, Girard says, the voices
confirmed his suspicion.
night I was going to bed; the usual drivel was going on,” he says.
“The constant stream of drivel. I was just about to go to bed, and a voice
says: ‘Mr. Girard, do you know who was in our studio with us? That was George
Bush, vice president of the United States.'”
STORY, HOWEVER STRANGE, reflects what TIs around the world report: a chance
encounter with a government agency or official, followed by surveillance and
gang stalking, and then, in many cases, voices, and pain similar to electric
shocks. Some in the community have taken it upon themselves to document as many
cases as possible. One TI from California conducted about 50 interviews,
narrowing the symptoms down to several major areas: “ringing in the ears,”
“manipulation of body parts,” “hearing voices,”
“piercing sensation on skin,” “sinus problems” and
“sexual attacks.” In fact, the TI continued, “many report the
sensation of having their genitalia manipulated.”
male and female TIs report a variety of “attacks” to their sexual
organs. “My testicles became so sore I could barely walk,” Girard
says of his early experiences. Others, however, report the attacks in the form
of sexual stimulation, including one TI who claims he dropped out of the
seminary after constant sexual stimulation by directed-energy weapons. Susan
Sayler, a TI in San Diego, says many women among the TIs suffer from attacks to
their sexual organs but are often embarrassed to talk about it with outsiders.
sporadic, you just never know when it will happen,” she says. “A lot
of the women say it’s as soon as you lay down in bed — that’s when you would
get hit the worst. It happened to me as I was driving, at odd times.”
made her think it was an electronic attack and not just in her head?
“There was no sexual attraction to a man when it would happen. That’s what
was wrong. It did not feel like a muscle spasm or whatever,” she says.
“It’s so . . . electronic.”
Naylor, a renowned African American writer, seems to defy many of the
stereotypes of someone who believes in mind control. A winner of the National
Book Award, Naylor is best known for her acclaimed novel, The Women of
Brewster Place, which described a group of women living in a poor urban
neighborhood and was later made into a miniseries by Oprah Winfrey.
in 2005, she published a lesser-known work, 1996, a
semi-autobiographical book describing her experience as a TI. “I didn’t
want to tell this story. It’s going to take courage. Perhaps more courage than
I possess, but they’ve left me no alternatives,” Naylor writes at the
beginning of her book. “I am in a battle for my mind. If I stop now,
they’ll have won, and I will lose myself.” The book is coherent, if hard
to believe. It’s also marked by disturbing passages describing how Jewish
American agents were responsible for Naylor’s surveillance. “Of the many
cars that kept coming and going down my road, most were driven by Jews,”
she writes in the book. When asked about that passage in a recent interview,
she defended her logic: Being from New York, she claimed, she can recognize
lives on a quiet street in Brooklyn in a majestic brownstone with an interior
featuring intricate woodwork and tasteful decorations that attest to a
successful literary career. She speaks about her situation calmly, occasionally
laughing at her own predicament and her struggle with what she originally
thought was mental illness. “I would observe myself,” she explains.
“I would lie in bed while the conversations were going on, and I’d ask:
Maybe it is schizophrenia?”
Girard, Naylor describes what she calls “street theater” — incidents
that might be dismissed by others as coincidental, but which Naylor believes
were set up. She noticed suspicious cars driving by her isolated vacation home.
On an airplane, fellow passengers mimicked her every movement — like mimes on
similar to those in Girard’s case followed — taunting voices cursing her,
telling her she was stupid, that she couldn’t write. Expletive-laced language
filled her head. Naylor sought help from a psychiatrist and received a
prescription for an antipsychotic drug. But the medication failed to stop the
voices, she says, which only added to her conviction that the harassment was
almost four years, Naylor says, the voices prevented her from writing. In 2000,
she says, around the time she discovered the mind-control forums, the voices
stopped and the surveillance tapered off. It was then that she began writing 1996
as a “catharsis.”
urged Naylor not to publish the book, saying she would destroy her reputation.
But she did publish, albeit with a small publishing house. The book was
generally ignored by critics but embraced by TIs.
is not the first writer to describe such a personal descent. Evelyn Waugh, one
of the great novelists of the 20th century, details similar experiences in The
Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold. Waugh’s book, published in 1957, has eerie
similarities to Naylor’s.
on a recuperative cruise, Pinfold begins to hear voices on the ship that he
believes are part of a wireless system capable of broadcasting into his head;
he believes the instigator recruited fellow passengers to act as operatives;
and he describes “performances” put on by passengers directed at him
yet meant to look innocuous to others.
wrote his book several years after recovering from a similar episode and
realizing that the voices and paranoia were the result of drug-induced hallucinations.
who hasn’t written a book since 1996, is now back at work on an
historical novel she hopes will return her to the literary mainstream. She
remains convinced that she was targeted by mind control. The many echoes of her
ordeal she sees on the mind-control forums reassure her she’s not crazy, she
course, some of the things she sees on the forum do strike her as crazy.
“But who I am to say?” she says. “Maybe I sound crazy to
TIS, SUCH AS ED MOORE, A YOUNG MEDICAL DOCTOR, take a slightly more skeptical
approach. He criticizes what he calls the “wacky claims” of TIs who
blame various government agencies or groups of people without any proof.
“I have yet to see a claim of who is behind this that has any data to support
it,” he writes.
Moore still believes the voices in his head are the result of mind control and
that the U.S. government is the most likely culprit. Moore started hearing
voices in 2003, just as he completed his medical residency in anesthesiology;
he was pulling an all-nighter studying for board exams when he heard voices
coming from a nearby house commenting on him, on his abilities as a doctor, on
his sanity. At first, he thought he was simply overhearing conversations
through walls (much as Waugh’s fictional alter ego first thought), but when no
one else could hear the voices, he realized they were in his head. Moore went
through a traumatic two years, including hospitalization for depression with
tries to convince friends and family that you are being electronically harassed
with voices that only you can hear,” he writes in an e-mail. “You
learn to stop doing that. They don’t believe you, and they become sad and
concerned, and it amplifies your own depression when you have voices screaming
at you and your friends and family looking at you as a helpless, sick, mentally
says he grew frustrated with anti-psychotic medications meant to stop the
voices, both because the treatments didn’t work and because psychiatrists
showed no interest in what the voices were telling him. He began to look for
some other way to cope.
March of 2005, I started looking up support groups on the Internet,” he
wrote. “My wife would cry when she would see these sites, knowing I still
heard voices, but I did not know what else to do.” In 2006, he says, his
wife, who had stood by him for three years, filed for divorce.
like other TIs, is cautious about sharing details of his life. He worries about
looking foolish to friends and colleagues — but he says that risk is
ultimately worthwhile if he can bring attention to the issue.
his father’s financial help, Moore is now studying for an electrical
engineering degree at the University of Texas at San Antonio, hoping to prove
that V2K, the technology to send voices into people’s heads, is real. Being in
school, around other people, helps him cope, he writes, but the voices continue
to taunt him.
he says, they told him: “We’ll never stop [messing] with you.”
WEEK BEFORE THE TIS RALLY ON THE NATIONAL MALL, John Alexander, one of the
people whom Harlan Girard holds personally responsible for the voices in his
head, is at a Chili’s restaurant in Crystal City explaining over a Philly
cheese steak and fries why the United States needs mind-control weapons.
former Green Beret who served in Vietnam, Alexander went on to a number of
national security jobs, and rubbed shoulders with prominent military and
political leaders. Long known for taking an interest in exotic weapons, his
1980 article, “The New Mental Battlefield,” published in the Army
journal Military Review, is cited by self-described victims as proof of his
complicity in mind control. Now retired from the government and living in Las
Vegas, Alexander continues to advise the military. He is in the Washington area
that day for an official meeting.
a shock of white hair is the mind of a self-styled military thinker. Alexander
belongs to a particular set of Pentagon advisers who consider themselves
defense intellectuals, focusing on big-picture issues, future threats and new
capabilities. Alexander’s career led him from work on sticky foam that would
stop an enemy in his or her tracks to dalliances in paranormal studies and
psychics, which he still defends as operationally useful.
an earlier phone conversation, Alexander said that in the 1990s, when he took
part in briefings at the CIA, there was never any talk of “mind control,
or mind-altering drugs or technologies, or anything like that.”
to Alexander, the military and intelligence agencies were still scared by the
excesses of MK-ULTRA, the infamous CIA program that involved, in part, slipping
LSD to unsuspecting victims. “Until recently, anything that smacked of
[mind control] was extremely dangerous” because Congress would simply take
the money away, he said.
acknowledged that “there were some abuses that took place,” but added
that, on the whole, “I would argue we threw the baby out with the bath
September 11, 2001, changed the mood in Washington, and some in the national
security community are again expressing interest in mind control, particularly
a younger generation of officials who weren’t around for MK-ULTRA. “It’s
interesting, that it’s coming back,” Alexander observed.
Alexander scoffs at the notion that he is somehow part of an elaborate plot to
control people’s minds, he acknowledges support for learning how to tap into a
potential enemy’s brain. He gives as an example the possible use of functional
magnetic resonance imaging, or fMRI, for lie detection. “Brain
mapping” with fMRI theoretically could allow interrogators to know when
someone is lying by watching for activity in particular parts of the brain. For
interrogating terrorists, fMRI could come in handy, Alexander suggests. But any
conceivable use of the technique would fall far short of the kind of
mind-reading TIs complain about.
also is intrigued by the possibility of using electronic means to modify
behavior. The dilemma of the war on terrorism, he notes, is that it never ends.
So what do you do with enemies, such as those at Guantanamo: keep them there
forever? That’s impractical. Behavior modification could be an alternative, he
I can fix you, or electronically neuter you, so it’s safe to release you into
society, so you won’t come back and kill me,” Alexander says. It’s only a
matter of time before technology allows that scenario to come true, he
continues. “We’re now getting to where we can do that.” He pauses for
a moment to take a bite of his sandwich. “Where does that fall in the
ethics spectrum? That’s a really tough question.”
Alexander encounters a query he doesn’t want to answer, such as one about the
ethics of mind control, he smiles and raises his hands level to his chest, as
if balancing two imaginary weights. In one hand is mind control and the
sanctity of free thought — and in the other hand, a tad higher — is the war
none of this has anything to do with the TIs, he says. “Just because
things are secret, people tend to extrapolate. Common sense does not prevail,
and even when you point out huge leaps in logic that just cannot be true, they
are not dissuaded.”
IS IT THAT BRINGS SOMEONE, EVEN AN INTELLIGENT PERSON, to ascribe the
experience of hearing disembodied voices to government weapons?
her book, Abducted, Harvard psychologist Susan Clancy examines a group
that has striking parallels to the TIs: people who believe they’ve been
kidnapped by aliens. The similarities are often uncanny: Would-be abductees
describe strange pains, and feelings of being watched or targeted. And although
the alleged abductees don’t generally have auditory hallucinations, they do
sometimes believe that their thoughts are controlled by aliens, or that they’ve
been implanted with advanced technology.
the online forum, some TIs posted vociferous objections to the parallel,
concerned that the public finds UFOs even weirder than mind control. “It
will keep us all marginalized and discredited,” one griped.)
argues that the main reason people believe they’ve been abducted by aliens is
that it provides them with a compelling narrative to explain their perception
that strange things have happened to them, such as marks on their bodies (marks
others would simply dismiss as bruises), stimulation to their sexual organs (as
the TIs describe) or feelings of paranoia. “It’s not just an explanation
for your problems; it’s a source of meaning for your life,” Clancy says.
the case of TIs, mind-control weapons are an explanation for the voices they
hear in their head. Socrates heard a voice and thought it was a demon; Joan of
Arc heard voices from God. As one TI noted in an e-mail: “Each person
undergoing this harassment is looking for the solution to the problem. Each
person analyzes it through his or her own particular spectrum of beliefs. If
you are a scientific-minded person, then you will probably analyze the
situation from that perspective and conclude it must be done with some kind of
electronic devices. If you are a religious person, you will see it as a
struggle between the elements of whatever religion you believe in. If you are
maybe, perhaps more eccentric, you may think that it is alien in nature.”
if you happen to live in the United States in the early 21st century, you may
fear the growing power of the NSA, CIA and FBI.
a victim of government surveillance is also, arguably, better than being
insane. In Waugh’s novella based on his own painful experience, when Pinfold
concludes that hidden technology is being used to infiltrate his brain, he
“felt nothing but gratitude in his discovery.” Why? “He might be
unpopular; he might be ridiculous; but he was not mad.”
Hoffman, a professor of psychiatry at Yale who has studied auditory
hallucinations, regularly sees people who believe the voices are a part of
government harassment (others believe they are God, dead relatives or even
ex-girlfriends). Not all people who hear voices are schizophrenic, he says,
noting that people can hear voices episodically in highly emotional states.
What exactly causes these voices is still unknown, but one thing is certain:
People who think the voices are caused by some external force are rarely
dissuaded from their delusional belief, he says. “These are highly
emotional and gripping experiences that are so compelling for them that
ordinary reality seems bland.”
because the experience is so vivid, he says, even some of those who improve
through treatment merely decide the medical regimen somehow helped protect
their brain from government weapons.
Temple, a professor of psychiatry at Penn State University who has been
involved in two recent studies of auditory hallucinations, notes that those who
suffer such hallucinations frequently lack insight into their illness. Even
among those who do understand they are sick, “that awareness comes and
goes,” he says. “People feel overwhelmed, and the delusional
AT THE PHILADELPHIA TRAIN STATION, Girard seems more agitated. In a meeting the
week before, his “handlers” had spoken to him only briefly — they
weren’t in the right position to attack him, Girard surmises, based on the lack
of voices. Today, his conversation jumps more rapidly from one subject to the
next: victims of radiation experiments, his hatred of George H.W. Bush,
MK-ULTRA, his personal experiences.
about his studies at Penn, he replies by talking about his problems with
reading: “I told you, everything I write they dictate to me,” he
says, referring again to the voices. “When I read, they’re reading to me.
My eyes go across; they’re moving my eyes down the line. They’re reading it to
me. When I close the book, I can’t remember a thing I read. That’s why they do
week before, Girard had pointed to only one person who appeared suspicious to
him — a young African American man reading a book; this time, however, he
hears more voices, which leads him to believe the station is crawling with
change our location,” Girard says after a while. “I’m sure they have
40 or 50 people in here today. I escaped their surveillance last time — they
won’t let that happen again.”
to explain the connection between mind control and the University of
Pennsylvania, which Girard alleges is involved in the conspiracy, he begins to
talk about defense contractors located near the Philadelphia campus: “General
Electric was right next to the parking garage; General Electric Space
Systems occupies a huge building right over there. From that building, you
could see into the studio where I was doing my work most of the time. I asked
somebody what they were doing there. You know, it had to do with computers. GE
Space Systems. They were supposed to be tracking missile debris from this
location . . . pardon me. What was your question again?”
many parts of Girard’s life seem to reflect that of any affluent 70-year-old
bachelor. He travels frequently to France for extended vacations and takes part
in French cultural activities in Philadelphia. He has set up a travel
scholarship at the Cleveland Institute of Art in the name of his late mother,
who attended school there (he changed his last name 27 years ago for
“personal reasons”), and he travels to meet the students who benefit
from the fund. And while the bulk of his time is spent on his research and
writing about mind control, he has other interests. He follows politics and
describes outings with friends and family members with whom he doesn’t talk
about mind control, knowing they would view it skeptically.
acknowledges that some of his experiences mirror symptoms of schizophrenia, but
asked if he ever worried that the voices might in fact be caused by mental
illness, he answers sharply with one word: “No.”
then, does he know the voices are real?
do you know you know anything?” Girard replies. “How do you know I
exist? How do you know this isn’t a dream you’re having, from which you’ll wake
up in a few minutes? I suppose that analogy is the closest thing: You know when
you have a dream. Sometimes it could be perfectly lucid, but you know it’s a
very “realness” of the voices is the issue — how do you disbelieve
something you perceive as real? That’s precisely what Hoffman, the Yale
psychiatrist, points out: So lucid are the voices that the sufferers –
regardless of their educational level or self-awareness — are unable to see
them as anything but real. “One thing I can assure you,” Hoffman
says, “is that for them, it feels real.”
LOOKS ALMOST LIKE ANY OTHER SMALL POLITICAL RALLY IN WASHINGTON. Posters adorn
the gate on the southwest side of the Capitol Reflecting Pool, as attendees set
up a table with press materials, while volunteers test a loudspeaker and set
out coolers filled with bottled water. The sun is out, the weather is perfect,
and an eclectic collection of people from across the country has gathered to protest
is not a tinfoil hat to be seen. Only the posters and paraphernalia hint at the
unusual. “Stop USA electronic harassment,” urges one poster.
“Directed Energy Assaults,” reads another. Smaller signs in the shape
of tombstones say, “RIP MKULTRA.” The main display, set in front of
the speaker’s lectern has a more extended message: “HELP STOP HI-TECH
ASSAULT PSYCHOTRONIC TORTURE.”
35 TIs show up for the June rally, in addition to a few friends and family
members. Speakers alternate between giving personal testimonials and
descriptions of research into mind-control technology. Most of the gawkers at
the rally are foreign tourists. A few hecklers snicker at the signs, but mostly
people are either confused or indifferent. The articles on mind control at the
table — from mainstream news magazines — go untouched.
can you expect people to get worked up over this if they don’t care about
eavesdropping or eminent domain?” one man challenges after stopping to
flip through the literature. Mary Ann Stratton, who is manning the table,
merely shrugs and smiles sadly. There is no answer: Everyone at the rally
acknowledges it is an uphill battle.
general, the outlook for TIs is not good; many lose their jobs, houses and
family. Depression is common. But for many at the rally, experiencing the
community of mind-control victims seems to help. One TI, a man who had been a
rescue swimmer in the Coast Guard before voices in his head sent him on a
downward spiral, expressed the solace he found among fellow TIs in a long
e-mail to another TI: “I think that the only people that can help are
people going through the same thing. Everyone else will not believe you, or
they are possibly involved.”
the end, though, nothing could help him enough. In August 2006, he would commit
at least for the day, the rally is boosting TI spirits. Girard, in what for him
is an ebullient mood, takes the microphone. A small crowd of tourists gathers
at the sidelines, listening with casual interest. With the Capitol looming
behind him, he reaches the crescendo of his speech, rallying the attendees to
remember an important thing: They are part of a single community.
heard it said, ‘We can’t get anywhere because everyone’s story is different.’
We are all the same,” Girard booms. “You knew someone with the power
to commit you to the electronic concentration camp system.”
weeks after the rally, Girard shows up for a meeting with a reporter at the
stately Mayflower Hotel in Washington, where he has stayed frequently over the
two decades he has traveled to the capital to battle mind control. He walks in
with a lit cigarette, which he apologetically puts out after a hotel employee
tells him smoking isn’t allowed anymore. He is half an hour late — delayed, he
says, by a meeting on Capitol Hill. Wearing a monogrammed dress shirt and tie,
he looks, as always, serious and professional.
declines to mention whom on Capitol Hill he’d met with, other than to say it
was a congressional staffer. Embarrassment is likely a factor: Girard readily
acknowledges that most people he meets with, ranging from scholars to
politicians, ignore his entreaties or dismiss him as a lunatic.
his focus is on his Web site, which he sees as the culmination of nearly a
quarter-century of research. When completed, it will contain more than 300
pages of documents. What next? Maybe he’ll move to France (there are victims
there, too), or maybe the U.S. government will finally just kill him, he says.
he is always searching for absolute proof that the government has decoded the
brain. His latest interest is LifeLog, a project once funded by the Pentagon
that he read about in Wired News. The article described it this way: “The
embryonic LifeLog program would dump everything an individual does into a giant
database: every e-mail sent or received, every picture taken, every Web page
surfed, every phone call made, every TV show watched, every magazine read. All
of this — and more — would combine with information gleaned from a variety of
sources: a GPS transmitter to keep tabs on where that person went, audiovisual
sensors to capture what he or she sees or says, and biomedical monitors to keep
track of the individual’s health.”
suggests that the government, using similar technology, has
“catalogued” his life over the past two years — every sight and
sound (Evelyn Waugh, in his mind-control book, writes about his character’s
similar fear that his harassers were creating a file of his entire life).
thinks the government can control his movements, inject thoughts into his head,
cause him pain day and night. He believes that he will die a victim of mind
there any reason for optimism?
hesitates, then asks a rhetorical question.
despite all this, why am I the same person? Why am I Harlan Girard?”
all his anguish, be it the result of mental illness or, as Girard contends,
government mind control, the voices haven’t managed to conquer the thing that
makes him who he is: Call it his consciousness, his intellect or, perhaps, his
what they don’t yet have,” he says. After 22 years, “I’m still
Sharon Weinberger is a Washington writer and author of Imaginary
Weapons: A Journey Through the Pentagon’s Scientific Underworld. She will be
fielding questions and comments about this article Tuesday at washingtonpost.com/liveonline.